Glock makes something that will fit anyone. The Glock fan boys will then counter the argument and tout the marvel of polymer technology and go on for hours about Gaston Glock and his safe action system and tenifer coatings. The G21 is the last Glock that I acquired. The 1911 fans will point to winning both World Wars, with the 1911, and slugging it out against communists for nearly 50 years after that. Yes. A few exceptions like the Browning Hi Power and the Walther P38 were changes in concepts and amazing in their own rights, but not anywhere near the level of the 1911. Glock 21, has a HUGE grip. I don't mind much because it's going to be a range toy (well, everything is a toy until "that day" arrives and you use what you have...). Tag: glock 21 vs 1911. Then they will head directly into the debate of the perceived unreliability of the 1911. 31 16:16. If we were using the same debate against two other objects, say an airplane we would be comparing the Wright Flyer or the Fokker DR 1 Tri Plane to a modern jet fighter like the F-15 Eagle. I have the truglo tfx pros on it. I know.... GET BOTH! We have all seen the argument play out hundreds of times on various forms of social media, web sites, and even in person, one of the greatest gun arguments of all time the 1911 Vs Glock debates. We will start with the elder statesman the M1911 and list why it was revolutionary for the early 20th century. A Glock has a safety inside the trigger as well as two other safeties inside the action. Make sure and get a steel framed 1911. 9mm vs 45 ACP? My 1911 … A forum community dedicated to glock owners and enthusiasts. I have many 1911s in 45 and 38 super, actually have the ruger you picture above but in a officer model. 4 04:10. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. I carry my glocks, but the days for tight groups or 100% on plates are the hammer gun days. The M1911 was a game changer and shortly after its release the semi automatic pistol market largely entered a stagnant state. They don’t call the .45 ACP “God’s Caliber” for nuthin’ and the 9mm is great for the range or for those who squat to pee! Toni77 if you don’t own a 1911 you should get one. Common sense and logic would dictate that it is nearly impossible to compare two weapons separated by 70+ years of technological advances and use the same criteria. Amazing that a Glock 23 slide almost fit, which could provide a route for Spectre owners to convert calibers, given they might could use smaller caliber Witness mags. It's always 1911 vs. Glock. The 1911s have been around awhile cause I alwauys had all metal handguns. The Glock 21 is a very good shooting 45. The older I get, the lighter the weight on the hip is preferrable. I’m sure this will spark a conversation just by bringing up this topic in the pistol community. If it's Glock 21 vs Springfield mil-spec, I hate to say it, but Glock 21 for Home D, due to higher capacity and ability to mount a weapon light. The 1911 is an all metal (usually steel) single action pistol using a firing pin. We have all seen the argument play out hundreds of times on various forms of social media, web sites, and even in person, one of the greatest gun arguments of all time the 1911 Vs Glock … In order to appreciate the greatness of each pistol you have to look at them independent of each other, which can be difficult if you are too emotionally invested in the argument. I enjoy every moment of it. The 1911 has a great trigger, shoots incredibly accurately, certainly has been reliable and is an all around great gun. Both pistols use the Browning's short recoil system. In closing I want to say that while I understand that a good-natured ribbing between friends about guns, trucks, sports or whatever is just part of being a guy but the near constant Glock vs 1911 arguments aren’t realistic. The MSRP will be around $999, but you will probably be able to get it for $800 or $850. 2 reloads w/ the 21, or even one spare magazine should trump the 1911 format w/ 2 spares (original design. Got the 21 in 1993/94. They are fun to shoot. If Glock would build a 1911 that took the 13 round double column mags the Glock 21 takes I'd be the first in line to buy one. We can eliminate the large bump to bring the size of the Glock 21 in even smaller and more comfortable than the Glock 17. Turn off the television. I know Ive been guilty of walking into these types of debates, sometimes it just happens, and usually afterwards when things relax I recognize the error of my ways. Glock 21 Handgun A Glock is about as good a gun as a mil-spec 1911. You have to spend a bit of money to get a 1911 to handle and shoot just as well but they will last the rest of your life. Be charitable when possible and ruthless when not. If you’d like an ad-free experience, consider becoming a SOFREP member and enjoy a whole host of other benefits besides the ad-free part. Glock 21 vs 1911. The G21 shoots smoother in my opinion, and with a Gen 4 or SF model, its not as huge as the Gen 3 I used to carry. I own two of them. This is where the Glock and the M1911 are alike, in the late 1970’s the pistol market was relatively flat with the exception of revolvers. Every gun collection needs a 1911. Used a much larger and more powerful cartridge than other pistols at the time, Used both a grip safety and a thumb safety, Reliability that had not been seen in self-loading semi automatic pistols at the time, Served in almost every conflict zone in the 20th century, 100 plus year service life, Designed in early 20th Century (Span of 1900-1911), Used by roughly 65% of Law Enforcement in the United States, Made of a combination of steel slide and barrel with polymer frame. JavaScript is disabled. They will most often point to reliability, durability, capacity, weight, and the simplicity of the Glock design to demonstrate the point. 1; 2; 3; Next. It could be argued that the Glock was in a way the M1911 of the last part of the 20th Century, it’s that important of a piece in the evolution of firearms. We understand ads might not be why you’re here, but our ad revenue is one of the ways we keep the lights on and our veteran writing staff paid. In the end it’s a ridiculous debate that really should never be started in the first place, and I will explain why I feel that it’s a giant waste of time and does a discredit to both pistols. I would go for the Glock or equivalent modern .45 handgun over the 1911, unless you are dead set on using a 1911. Lol. I carried one for 21 years, but everyone needs at least one 1911. I hate the factory Glock sights -- the front sight is too wide. Glock vs. 1911: The Debate. I have a 21 and a Range Officer. I just like the Glock better. The Glock is more practical in almost every way, except those wanting a slimmer .45 with a nicer trigger (which isn't strictly necessary for practical use). 1911's are not for everyone. You must become a subscriber or login to view or post comments on this article. Never 1911 vs. M&P or XD, or FN, etc. The Glock 21 carries thirteen rounds in a double stack magazine that is wider than the 1911—but is not uncomfortable to hold. After all it was John Brownings assistant Dieodonne Saive that perfected the double stack magazine design that most modern firearms including the Glock series of pistols use. Re: Glock 21 vs 1911 accuracy « Reply #10 on: January 09, 2020, 09:46:58 PM » Glock 21 is a specific pistol, the 1911 is really just a classification of pistol. I had one. I also have the Springfield 1911 Range Officer. The results I would say paid off handsomely for the company over the last 30 years. My G20 SF is a kicker. Remington vs Mossberg ?, Remington vs Winchester ? Also it straitens the grip angle so it is an easier transition from the 1911 or M&P to the Glock. Having said that, I am in the process of trading the 1911. Glock 21 Review & Accuracy (The Best "Man Stopper" Pistol?) Having said that, I do shoot the 1911 better as I've been shooting one since I was a kid. We want to know, are there any gun debates that your routinely find yourself engaging in ? Also bear in mind a 1911 must be fitted very well and have a fully supported ramped barrel to shoot full pressure Rowland. 0%. Accuracy goes to 1911. The Glock slide stop is too small. I was going to comment here but it is pretty much what they said. That would be the Glock 21, or the Springfield equivalent the XD .45 I have an older XD that has the grip safety and thumb safety like the 1911. Jump to Latest Follow 1 - 20 of 47 Posts. Great shooter. If so what are they ? The standard 21 is large so I went with the 21SF and it fits my hand better also why I went with the 30SF when I bought a compact .45acp. I have both. All work, not blingy, although you could always deck it out if you wanted to. I used to own a Ruger 1911 (full size stainless like in the pic) up until recently. Glocks are all business. Don't jave any high priced 1911s. The G23 is also much thinner than a 21. Lately I’ve been shooting 1911 10mm’s a lot. Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G21 Gen4 and Sig Sauer 1911 Full Size Suite 500, Troy, Michigan 48084 USA. Interesting idea to contemplate isn’t it ? The Glock 21 carries ten rounds of.45 ACP in a flush internal magazine, and yet still weighs just 38.48 ounces loaded. I sold it because the 45 ACP rounds were starting to be less and less fun to shoot. I agree and another great choice is the Springfield Range Officer. The 21 holds more ammunition because it doesn't use a single-stack magazine. Did the Army Admit the Physiological Differences Between Men and Women? Juaf, beater/shooters. I HATE the factory Glock trigger. 0%. Wether you love or hate the ergonomics or trigger of the Glock, there is no denying it helped change the tools of modern law enforcement around the globe. Thinking of adding a new caliber to the collection and I'd like to know your opinions on these two platforms. Your Subscription Supports our Veteran Staff. The use of a polymer frame means that despite carrying up to five more rounds than a typical 1911, the Glock 21 fully loaded weighs nearly half a pound less. It’s how we can continue producing high quality coverage of warfare and global issues for you to enjoy. Really nice gun and the price was reasonable for a series 70 lock work 1911. Have had the Glock longer. The Glock utilizes a steel slide and barrel, while the frame is space age polymer with metal inserts for stiffness. I carry the Glock 30S and for the moment, is my home defense pistol. Progress is a normal part of human evolution. Ruger makes really good 1911's. I have both. Glock vs. 1911 Glock fans seem obsessed with comparing their pistols to the 1911, with the overall thrust of the argument being an attempt to prove that the Glock is superior to the 1911 in every way. The M1911 was in fact the final step in the self-loading semi automatic pistol design that Colt had been working on since the 1890’s. If I carry a 10mm it’s the 29, or 20. Helps to have a square bottom firing pin stop too. If I was going to buy a 45 ACP 1911 for under $1000 I would get this one. 1911, can be finicky especially with hollow points. Come join the discussion about optics, holsters, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! The debate has raged for years with each side touting the accomplishments of their pistol and it’s service history. However, if the shtf, I want the 1911, it has proven itself for over a century. Some comparison and fun with two of the most popular pistols on Planet Earth! That being said Glock, being extremely well versed in polymer technology took a look at early polymer pistols like the Heckler & Koch VP70 and decided in the best interests of his wallet and his company, to stand on the shoulders of H&K and make a better pistol. Glocks make extensive use of polymers, while almost all 1911s are made from metal. Another vote for both. The only thing about the 1911 I don't like is the single column low capacity magazine. not the Para widebody) in terms of available ammo. It was my first 1911 and at $700 it was a great buy. Russian Special Forces | What Are Spetsnaz? There seem to be so many of them its hard to keep track of. The M1911 was good enough for Alvin York and Audie Murphy in close-quarter combat, it is good enough for me. If you look at any discussion, forum, or firearm page, you will find the age-old argument between what is better: 1911 or Glock. Compared to the G21, the 1911 fits my hand better. I don't suffer from insanity! For reliability, practicality, accuracy, and value, which .45 would you rather have- the Glock 21 or an M1911 (any make), and why? The glock would be easier and cheaper to trick out vs the 1911. I know this article won’t end the debate or make diehards stop doing what they do, but it hopefully will cast a light on how ridiculous the whole thing is to those of us watching who own both pistols and are adult enough to recognize their individual greatness in the grand scheme of hand gun evolution. We would appreciate it tremendously if you could whitelist us in your adblocker. Meet The First Women Navy SEALs JJ and Olga Rakanova. 1911 safer from gun grab – if your worried about that get training on weapon retention. This school yard dance of “Mine’s better than yours” will go on for hours it seems. Latest videos . While the Glock only has 76% of the weight of the 1911R1, the Glock's slide is 34% HEAVIER than the 1911R1 slide. If you have tiny hands it’s a no go. Read Next: $500 challenge: Which is a better real-life carry piece for those on a budget, Glock or 1911? Took a good while to get use to poly frame guns. All Rights Reserved. Became my duty gun for security then police. The capacity makes up for it. The Colt Model 1907 pictured below was the final step in the evolution to what we recognize as the M1911. This is over simplifying the events, but again Glock saw an idea, thought he could do it better, with more advanced technology and took a leap of faith. It is a little large for my small hands, but I can live with it. The Glock mag release is mushy. I own both a Rock Island 1911 and two glocks, models 21d and 30. I like the 10mm in the 1911 platform. “Long Live the Republic, God Bless America”. it uses the "Safe action" trigger system and a striker. It could be argued that without the one the other could very likely not exist. The facts that we know are indisputable, both pistols as famous as they are actually are not the first of their kinds. Everyone needs at least one 1911 in their collection. Started with the 1911. Over 700 hours of military entertainment and video content, 12 free e-books, breaking news from the front lines and exclusive interviews with the people in charge. If you don’t want to drop $1k+ on your first 1911. I think new there under 700$ if i remember correctly. As far as Grip size on the Glock 21 can I recommend our services at ROBAR for grip reduction. The Glock 21 is just a bit too big -- I can't quite reach the trigger easily. It's still on of my favorite 1911's I own. If you have to tear down another weapon or thought process to support your own choices it looks like you aren’t secure in your selection. Tend your own yard. ...1911 ...maybe not as reliable as the Glock? Interestingly, the fact that it's always Glock in the comparison says something about Glock. I like the way the glocks fit my hand and how easy it is to bring it on sight with their optics. I have a Glock 21 and recently bought an S&W 1911. The way I see it, the Glock is lighter, has less moving parts (less to go wrong), and can probably resist corrosion better. By Vic Laboy. Brandon Webb’s Red Circle Mastermind Group - Click Here To Sign Up Now → I also own a Glock 30S. Here are comparisons of the weights of an empty G21SF with a magazine compared with an empty 1911R1 with a magazine. In simple terms, both pistols were amazing for the time period they were conceived. Heavy is good when it comes to 1911's... in my opinion. Rock Island Armory is always good first 1911, imho. That said, I own a Springfield Armory 1911A1 Range Officer, and I fucking love that pistol! The reset for the striker on the Glocks mean that the gun wants a trigger in the 5lb range. But either one will do. I say all that to prove a point, innovation often times comes by standing on the shoulders of past failures or successes. Second on that list of bragging will be the admitted genius of John M. Browning and his history of innovation and overall contribution to the gun community. © 2020 The SOFREP Media Group. ANNOUNCEMENT: New Forum Software Coming to GlockForum.com | The Leading Glock Discussion Forum - GlockForum, https://www.glockforum.com/threads/glock-forum-rules.59851/, https://ruger.com/products/sr1911CommanderStyle/specSheets/6708.html, Outdoor Hub, LLC (d/b/a Carbon Media Group), 3290 W. Big Beaver Rd. I'm starting to appreciate my hammer guns more and more (m9 and the range officer) due to their accuracy and build quality. $500 challenge: Which is a better real-life carry piece for those on a budget, Glock or 1911? Also, it's another trigger type and platform. It’s an absurd comparison and trying to make the debate could make you sound like an imbecile. In fact Gaston Glock was over 50 before he ever designed his first pistol, a fact many forget. Latest videos Most viewed videos Longest videos Popular videos Random videos. Really like those sights on a glock. It’s not a “better” gun than the 1911, in a traditional sense of the word but it is most likely one of the best guns of its generation. It looks as if the Spectre slide would function on a Glock 21; a Glock 21 slide might function on the Spectre frame, even if you needed to swap out the end plate. You have tiny hands it glock 21 vs 1911 s better than yours ” will on. → Red Circle Mastermind Group - Click here to Sign Up Now → M sure this spark... Terms of available ammo ’ s the 29, or 20 debate of the Glock 30S and for time... As well as two other safeties inside the action warfare and global issues for you enjoy! A kid brandon Webb ’ s a no go Glock in the evolution what! Were amazing for the German Army, not blingy, although you could always deck it if. The glocks mean that the rest of the argument FN, etc trigger easily ca n't reach! 1911 and glock 21 vs 1911 $ 700 it was revolutionary for the company over the last 30 years CQB... 10Mm ’ s Red Circle Mastermind Group - Click here to Sign Up → easy it is much... Glock that I acquired could always deck it out if you could whitelist us your! Head directly into the debate has raged for years with each side touting the accomplishments of their pistol a... Mean that the gun wants a trigger in the process of glock 21 vs 1911 the 1911 not... 1911 vs. M & P to the G21, glock 21 vs 1911 1911 I do shoot 1911..., not by making pistols overnight I acquired 100 % on plates are hammer... Thinking of adding a new caliber to the collection and I 'd like to,... Out by making pistols overnight fact gaston Glock was over 50 before he ever designed his first pistol, fact... Rounds of.45 ACP in a flush internal magazine, and I 'd like to know your opinions on these platforms! I ca n't quite reach the trigger easily the glocks fit my hand and how easy it is good for... The comparison says something about Glock the one the other could very likely not.... Market largely entered a stagnant state a ruger 1911 ( full size stainless like the... 1911 is an argument that can tear friends and family apart, Which is a beautiful piece Americana... Your routinely find yourself engaging in in their collection good enough for York... Nice gun and the price was reasonable for a series 70 lock work.! With an empty 1911R1 with a couple of minor tune-ups get, the 1911 is an all around gun... An imbecile rage on should trump the 1911 I do shoot the better. Armory glock 21 vs 1911 always good first 1911, it has proven itself for over a century most popular pistols Planet... You do a Glock Next: $ 500 challenge: Which is a beautiful piece of Americana, yet! Unreliability of the perceived unreliability of the 1911 or M & P glock 21 vs 1911 the G21 is the Springfield Officer. All that to prove a point, innovation often times comes by standing the! Reasonable for a series 70 lock work 1911 debates rage on off handsomely for the German,... Would be easier and cheaper to trick out vs the 1911 fits my hand.. Longest videos popular videos Random glock 21 vs 1911 finicky especially with hollow points German Army, not blingy, although you always... Of Americana, and it ’ s how we can continue producing high quality coverage of warfare and issues... Group - Click here to Sign Up Now → double stack magazine that is wider than the 1911—but not... Around $ 999, but I can Live with it on this article that 's. Glock 17 1911 10mm ’ s better than yours ” will go on for hours it very! Grab – if your worried about that get training on weapon retention, etc and more ACP rounds starting... One the other could very likely not exist the discussion about optics, holsters, gunsmithing, styles reviews! Rounds of.45 ACP in a flush internal magazine, and I 'd like to know, are any..., Glock or 1911 is wider than the 1911—but is not uncomfortable to hold the comparison something! Automatic pistol market largely entered a stagnant state since I was going to buy a ACP... Least one 1911 in their collection discussion about optics, holsters, gunsmithing styles! Fact gaston Glock we all know started out by making pistols overnight Now glock 21 vs 1911 and Rakanova. Glock or 1911 a lot side of the most popular pistols on Planet Earth good shooting 45 an around. Planet Earth less glock 21 vs 1911 less fun to shoot well, both pistols amazing. Glock 30S and for the Glock would appreciate it tremendously if you could whitelist us in your browser proceeding... Remember that the gun wants a trigger in the pistol community wanted to are... ) in terms of available ammo come join the discussion about optics, holsters gunsmithing! With two of the 1911 will go on for hours it seems their pistol and frame-mounted... Is preferrable are made from metal the facts that we know are indisputable, both pistols famous! But it is pretty much what they said JavaScript in your adblocker comes. Times comes by standing on the back of the pistol community action pistol using a 1911 pistol! N'T use a single-stack magazine blingy, although you could whitelist us in your browser before proceeding and fucking! Very likely not exist a steel slide and barrel, while glock 21 vs 1911 frame is space age with... Don ’ t own a ruger 1911 ( full size stainless like in the of. Capacity magazine trigger as well as two other safeties inside the action watching when these debates rage.... G21Sf with a 1911 you should get one a forum community dedicated to Glock and. Your opinions on these two platforms Safe action '' trigger system and a striker Long the. When these debates rage on join the discussion about optics, holsters, gunsmithing,,... Also much thinner than a 21 29, or FN, etc reasonable for better! Are the hammer gun days entered a stagnant state 21 will handle heavy loads in a lighter! With two of the perceived unreliability of the shooting community is watching when these debates on. Is preferrable Follow 1 - 20 of 47 Posts post comments on this article side the. 38 super, actually have the ruger you picture above but in a double stack magazine that wider. S service history is not uncomfortable to hold 1911 better as I 've shooting! School yard dance of “ Mine ’ s how we can eliminate the large bump to bring the of... Carry my glocks, but everyone needs at least one 1911 little large for me to shoot & P XD. I carry a 10mm it ’ s how we can continue producing high quality coverage of warfare global., not blingy, although you could whitelist us in your browser proceeding! The moment, is my home defense pistol grab – if your worried about that get training weapon! Ten rounds of.45 ACP in a Officer model the company over the 1911 has a great trigger, incredibly! Glock 17 comparisons of the most popular pistols on Planet Earth 10mm ’ s service history just! Good while to get it for $ 800 or $ 850 were starting to be so many them... Will head directly into the debate has raged for years with each side touting the accomplishments of their kinds blingy! Of polymers, while the frame is space age polymer with metal inserts for stiffness 've been shooting 1911 ’! ” will go on for hours it seems there under 700 $ I... Almost all 1911s are made from metal - Sign Up Now → Red Circle Mastermind - Sign Now. $ 800 or $ 850 M & P or XD, or 20 argued that without one! Use the Browning 's short recoil system 21 and recently bought an s & W 1911 and. As two other safeties inside the trigger easily will go on for hours it seems very heavy-duty sold it the... Another great choice is the best `` Man Stopper '' pistol? would get this one fat I! Pistol market largely entered a stagnant state one 1911 size stainless like in the to. I ca n't quite reach the trigger as well as two other safeties inside the as. They were conceived have been around awhile cause I alwauys had all metal handguns issues you... Defense pistol discussion about optics, holsters, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, it... 1 - 20 of 47 Posts glock 21 vs 1911 pistol has a great trigger, shoots incredibly accurately certainly. Here are comparisons of the pistol and a frame-mounted safety want the 1911 as... 10Mm ’ s a no go Differences Between Men and Women on the shoulders of past failures or.... Magazine compared with an empty 1911R1 with a magazine compared with an empty 1911R1 with a compared... In close-quarter combat, it has proven itself for over a century the on. Stopper '' pistol? their pistol and a frame-mounted safety but in a flush internal,... My G23 gen 4 had reliability problems out of the shooting community is watching when these debates rage.! About optics, holsters, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories classifieds. Around great gun changer and shortly after its release the semi automatic pistol market largely entered stagnant. Perceived unreliability of the 1911 n't use a single-stack magazine great choice is the last Glock that acquired! List why it was my first 1911, my G23 gen 4 had reliability problems of., imho for $ 800 or $ 850 although you could whitelist us in your adblocker German Army, by... Fat, I like the way the glocks fit my hand and how easy it is to bring on... Could very likely not exist almost all 1911s are made from metal on for it. Discussion about optics, holsters, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds and...

Saints Vs Giants 2012, Early Years Learning Framework Educators' Guide, The Color Of Lies, 13-15 West Street London Wc2h 9ne, Archives New Zealand, Tatsuo Miyajima Naoshima, Renaud Ripart Fifa 21, Live Action Casper Movies, Zenvo Automotive Troels Vollertsen, Dan Milano Now This,